The size that works is smaller than the size that feels productive
A deficit means eating below what you spend. Everything else — meal timing, food choice, which app you use — sits downstream of that. The question that actually matters is how large the gap should be, and the intuitive answer is usually too large.
A deficit of roughly 500 calories a day corresponds approximately to a pound a week. It is an approximation rather than a physical law: expenditure adapts as weight falls, so the same deficit yields progressively less over months.
A larger deficit does produce faster loss, for a while. The costs arrive later and are easy to miss at the start.
A useful frame is proportional rather than absolute. A 500-calorie deficit is modest against a TDEE of 3,000 and severe against a TDEE of 1,600. Someone smaller or less active generally needs a smaller absolute gap, and should expect slower loss as a consequence — not as a failure.
Public health material commonly treats roughly 1,200 calories a day for women and 1,500 for men as a lower bound for unsupervised dieting. These are rules of thumb rather than clinical thresholds, and they exist mainly because below them nutritional adequacy becomes hard to achieve from food.
Very-low-calorie programmes below these figures do exist and can be appropriate — but they are medically supervised, with bloodwork and supplementation. That supervision is the difference. It is not something to reproduce alone from a website.
Loss slowing after a few months is expected, not a malfunction. A lighter body spends less, so the original deficit has shrunk in real terms. The responses, in rough order of preference: recalculate TDEE at your current weight, then look honestly at portion drift and untracked intake, then consider adding activity before cutting further. Repeatedly cutting calories to chase the same rate is how people arrive at intakes they cannot sustain.
When to involve a provider first. If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, under 18, managing diabetes or another chronic condition, taking medication affected by intake or weight, or have any history of disordered eating, start with a clinician rather than a calculator. This page describes general public health guidance, not advice for your circumstances.
Free, instant, and nothing you enter leaves your browser.
Open the Calorie Calculator